Key Retirement Question: Rent Or Own?

    There are 10,000 Baby Boomers retiring every day for another 14 years, which means a lot of people have a choice that will have a monumental impact on their retirement: Rent or own?

    Wait a minute. Didn’t they settle that question 20 or 30 years ago?

    Yes and home ownership was a runaway winner. The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau says that 33 million Americans 65 and older (80 percent) own their home. About 23 million people in that group have paid off their mortgage so they own it free and clear, meaning they could sell it and pocket all the proceeds.

    Home prices have risen 20 percent nationally from January of 2012 to March of 2015, a period that coincides almost perfectly with the Baby Boomer generation easing into retirement age. Forecasts are for that trend to continue, which puts Boomers in an enviable position: Sell their home, add a huge chunk of change to their retirement savings and then … what?

    Rent or own during retirement years?

    “There really is no pat answer for that because there are so many things to consider,” said Dr. Joan Koonce, a professor at the University of Georgia’s prestigious Financial Planning department. “What are your retirement goals? What kind of lifestyle do you want? Do you have the financial and physical ability to keep up with the demands of home ownership?

    “There are a lot of questions that have to be answered before you make this choice.”

    Stability In Ownership

    There are compelling arguments to be made on both sides.

    If you own a home, chances are you have lived there for a long time and are comfortable with the environment. You are familiar with your neighbors and your neighborhood. You know where the grocery market, restaurants, church, doctor’s office and hospital are and how long it takes to get there.

    Some other factors favoring home ownership include:

    • No fear of rent increases or being evicted.
    • You can modify living space as needed if you become disabled at any time.
    • You can plant a garden, add a pool/patio/grotto or paint the house without asking permission.
    • Pets permitted (or not).
    • Tax break on mortgage and property.

    On the other side of the table are people who see retirement as a new adventure in life. If you are in good health and on stable financial ground – mortgage paid, no credit card debt, own your car and have no student loan payments lingering – the chance to walk away from the responsibility of home ownership might be just the ticket.

    Freedom From Responsibility

    The biggest plus for renting is flexibility in living arrangements. No more 15-or 30-year commitments. If you don’t like your neighborhood, rent a place in another part of town. Tired of winters? Rent a home/condo/apartment in a warmer climate. Always wanted to live on a beach? They have rentals there, too.

    And the beauty of all that is if you don’t like the new spot, you can pick up and go as soon your lease expires. Some of the other benefits suddenly on the rental side include:

    • No responsibility for maintenance. If the roof leaks, the plumbing needs repairs, the trees need trimming, call the landlord.
    • Perfect time to downsize. Why take care of a 5/3 when all you really need is a 2/2?
    • Find a residence that accommodates your age. No more stairs, if you don’t want them.
    • Get closer to family. If your children have relocated, you can, too.
    • Considerably less up-front costs. Deposit vs. down payment. A big win for renters.
    • No more property taxes.
    • No more home insurance.

    The last three factors are economic advantages that can considerably improve your retirement savings. Part of the profits from the sale of your home could be re-invested in the stock market to generate income while you play out the Golden Years. So could money not spent on taxes and insurance.

    “The price of renting doesn’t necessarily mean you’re going to automatically come out of head,” Dr. Koonce said. “Also, owning a home means you are building equity and if you need to pay for some type of care later in life, that equity might come in handy.

    “But there are some real hassles involved in owning a home and you have to decide if you want to spend your resources on that. It’s a tough choice that people are going to have to make.”


    Bill Fay
    Staff Writer

    Bill “No Pay” Fay has lived a meager financial existence his entire life. He started writing/bragging about it seven years ago, helping birth into existence as the site’s original “Frugal Man.” Prior to that, he spent more than 30 years covering college and professional sports, which are the fantasy worlds of finance. His work has been published by the Associated Press, New York Times, Washington Post, Chicago Tribune, Sports Illustrated and Sporting News, among others. His interest in sports has waned some, but his interest in never reaching for his wallet is as passionate as ever. Bill can be reached at

    In debt? We can help!

    • Amount
    • Type
    • Contact

    How much do you owe?

    What can we help you with today?

    Related Articles

    Older couple sitting with papers and considering bankruptcy

    Retirees and Bankruptcy

    People are supposed to relax when they retire, not worry about financial problems. Studies show that a lot of retirees turn to alcohol for debt relief, but there is a better way than booze:  Bankruptcy.The mere word makes a lot of people cringe, ...

    Continue Reading
    myRA Account is my retirement account

    MyRA Account Starting Point For Retirement Savings

    The United States government is opening the door to retirement savings for the millions of Americans who have nothing invested there, but a word of caution if you go inside: There’s not much to see.The federal government is offering a retirement account ...

    Continue Reading
    Jar full of coins intended for a 401K savings plan

    Employers Up The Ante On 401k Plans

    There is a new twist on the ages old discussion about how much is needed for retirement savings: Employers – not employees! – are taking the initiative.The Vanguard Group, an investment management company, said that 36 percent of the companies it ...

    Continue Reading
    Large cost for education

    Workers Put Paying For Child’s College Ahead Of Retirement Savings

    American workers have found another escape hatch to avoid contributing to their retirement savings and at least 33 percent of them say they would voluntarily take it.The LIMRA Secure Retirement Institute released a study that said one-third of U.S. ...

    Continue Reading
    Senior Student Debt

    Social Security Checks At Risk As Seniors Take On Student Loans

    Wanda Russell had just turned 50 when her bosses told her she would have to go back to college and get a bachelor of nursing degree to keep her job.Russell gulped. Back to college? At this stage of my career?Russell was an assistant nurse manager for ...

    Continue Reading
    Baby boomers have enough to retire

    Baby Boomers Better Prepared for Retirement than Previous Generations

    A new report says that most baby boomers have successfully stuffed enough pennies into the piggy banks – and dollars into the 401(k) plans – to retain their status as the most pampered generation in America, even in retirement.Americans have put away ...

    Continue Reading
    Signing Will

    No Cash for a Will? Leave a Fond Memory Instead

     As a growing number of retirees come to grips with their dwindling cash flows to leave as inheritance, many are turning to other ways to preserve their memory for future generations. Gone are the days that an inheritance means a big ...

    Continue Reading
    teen taking money

    Teens Are Counting on Parents to Finance Retirements, Study Shows

    Attention moms and dads: your teens are counting on you for more than a few bucks for a movie or some new clothes. They’re depending on you to pay for their retirements too. About 40 percent of young Americans aged 13 to 22 are expecting an ...

    Continue Reading
    Get Help Now

    Overwhelmed with debt? You have options for lower monthly payments!